1847 – 1852 Father Joseph Kundek (Founded St. Boniface as a Mission of St. Ferdinand)
1852 – 1853 Father Henry Peters (First Resident Pastor)
1853 Father Bede O’Connor, OSB (First Benedictine Pastor)
1853 Father Eugene Schwerzmann, OSB
1854 Father Jerome Bachman, OSB
1854 Father Ulrich Christen, OSB
1854 – 1858 Father Bede O’Connor, OSB
1858 – 1861 Father John Chrysostom Foffa, OSB
1861 – 1863 Father Martin Marty, OSB (First Abbot of Saint Meinrad; became Bishop of Dakota Territory in 1880)
1863 – 1865 Father Henry Hug, OSB
1865 – 1869 Father Wolfgang Schlumpf, OSB
1869 Father Isidore Hobi, OSB
1870 – 1871 Father Placidus Zarn, OSB
1871 – 1877 Father Benno Gerber, OSB
1877 Father Jerome Hunt, OSB
1877 – 1881 Father Maurus Helferich, OSB (Brought first three Benedictine sisters from Ferdinand –
Sister Scholastica, Sister Faustina, and Sister Martina)
1881 – 1890 Father Augustine Falley, OSB
1890 – 1926 Father Joseph Villinger, OSB
1926 Father Philip Bauer, OSB
1926 – 1927 Father Gregory Kunkler, OSB
1927 – 1930 Father Paul Thoma, OSB
1930 – 1945 Father Mark Meyer, OSB
1945 – 1957 Father Charles Dudine, OSB
1957 Father Donald Walpole, OSB
1957 Father Bernard Beck, OSB
1957 – 1960 Father Matthew Preske, OSB
1960 – 1973 Father Edwin Miller, OSB
1973 – 1983 Father Alan McIntosh, OSB
1983 – 1985 Father Eugene Hensell, OSB, with assistants:
Father Damian Schmelz, OSB
Father Gregory Chamberlin, OSB
Father Noah Casey, OSB
Father Jonathan Fassero, OSB
Father Nicholas Taylor, OSB
Brother Guerric DeBona, OSB (Deacon)
1985 – 1986 Father Ralph Lynch, OSB
Brother Rene Bouillon, OSB (Pastoral Associate until 1989)
1986 Father Simon McTighe, OSB
1986 Father Pius Klein, OSB
1986 Father Simon McTighe, OSB
1986 – 1987 Father Alban Berling, OSB
1987 – 1990 Father Warren Heitz, OSB
1990 – 1991 Father Cyril Vrablic, OSB
1991 – 1995 Father Jeremy King, OSB
1995 – 1997 Father Sean Hoppe, OSB
1997 – 2002 Father Jeremy King, OSB
1997 – 2000 Father Adrian Burke, OSB (Associate Pastor)
2002 – 2004 Father Brendan Moss, OSB
2004 – 2009 Father Adrian Burke, OSB
2009 – present Father Anthony Vinson, OSB
2014 – present Father John McMullen, OSB (Associate Priest for Sacramental Assistance)